The media industry has been disrupted. Falling advertising revenues make many publishers anxiously eye their balance sheets. Especially small outlets are struggling. As a consequence, many of them are hesitant to invest in data journalism, fearing that it would lead to additional costs.
In the UK – usually seen as a vanguard when it comes to data journalism – local news outlets struggle to keep up. “Even the British media system, where data journalism is generally well embedded into the news cycle suffers from a central-regional divide due to scarce human and economic resources in smaller news outlets”, writes Colin Porlezza.
The importance of data journalism for small newsrooms and local outlets
Yet, now more than ever before data journalism is important for smaller newsrooms and outlets. According to Kira Schacht, a German data journalist, “telling a story with data often provides a way of conveying a bigger picture, while illustrating local implications by highlighting a localized aspect of a dataset.” Schacht, who is also the co-founder of the German data journalism start-up Journocode is convinced that data-driven reporting helps smaller outlets stand out and to provide a unique experience to their audience. “Finally”, Schacht argues “data-driven methods can also help aid the watchdog role of journalism, which is especially needed in local journalism.”
But if data journalism is so important to small newsrooms and local outlets how can we make sure that they, too, can participate? In order to find out how small newsrooms can successfully harness the full potential of data journalism, I interviewed leading industry experts, data journalists and heads of data teams in Germany, Austria and the United Kingdom . Some worked for small outlets or non-profit investigative bureaus, others for major newspapers.
Here are my main findings:
- Data journalism is teamwork. Simon Rogers, who started the Guardian’s Datablog and now heads the “Google News Lab”, described his data journalism “dream team” as a group of six to seven people – a number that is consistent across all the outlets I interviewed. Notably, the size of the newsroom does not make a difference to the size of the data team. The teams are often a mix of data journalists, programmers and developers, many of them not coming from a traditional journalism background. For instance, at Spiegel Online a former city planner and a physicist are working on data journalism projects, while other outlets have hired people with a computer science background.
- Being small can be an advantage. “If you have got a leader who is committed to innovation, it should be easier to turn around a small newsroom”, says The Guardian’s former editor-in-chief Alan Rusbridger. In general, less in-house expertise is not necessarily a disadvantage. According to Megan Lucero who leads The Bureau of Investigative Journalism’s Bureau Local, “it is much easier for smaller newsrooms to change and introduce new things; this is your new resource.” She opines that smaller organisations can easier pair up with academics and researchers which can give them an edge in their reporting. Yet, finding common ground regarding different approaches and priorities as well as workflows and deadlines is essential.”
- Shake off the dust with data skills. The case study of the Berliner Morgenpost illustrates how data journalism can change the organisational culture of a local newspaper. Julius Tröger started doing data journalism from scratch. Within a few years, he and his growing team were able to do award-winning data journalism. The Berliner Morgenpost, suffering from its old-fashioned image in the past, currently boasts some of the best data journalism in the German-speaking world.
- Diversification: Data journalism can take many different forms and shapes. With data journalism, it is possible to tell a different story for everyone – a unique selling point of online journalism. Whether it is drawing the former GDR border or guessing how unemployment dropped during Barack Obama’s US presidency: Users like to interact, and those exercises can be quite educational, too. Finally, there is also room for self-collected data stories and crowd-sourced journalism
The crucial point, however, is which steps small newsrooms can take to improve their data journalism efforts and to form a data journalism team – all while taking care of their limited budget. My research has allowed me to come up with the following list.
Ten steps for small newsrooms to get started with data journalism
- Set reasonable goals: A data visualisation, a page with data, a graph, or deep month-long data-driven research – all that’s data journalism. Yet, it is vital that the projects and expectations towards data journalism suit the outlet. Think about what your data team can achieve and what you want them to achieve, and then set it up accordingly.
- Commitment from the top: “None of it stands a chance if you don’t have an editor in chief who believes in it”, says Alan Rusbridger. He is not the only one to emphasize the importance of committed leadership. “The barriers are mainly about culture and leadership now, not about technology”, digital strategist Nic Newman confirms.
- Enthusiasm on the bottom: While a vision is certainly required, more often than not a bottom-up initiative and some preliminary results are the means to convince a sceptical editorial board.
- Communication is essential: In order to achieve lasting change in a newsroom, communication is essential. Alan Rusbridger again: “The only way to create change was to constantly make people talk about it.”
- Build up skills: There are three ways of bringing the skills required for a data journalism team into a newsroom: 1) Train your staff, for example by offering workshops, 2) Bring in expertise by hiring data journalists, developers and/or programmers, 3) Collaborate with others newsrooms or experts such data scientists and analysts.
- Hire a few geeks
- Give the team (and the geeks) room and resources
- Cooperate: The data journalism community in Germany is rather small and very responsive. Even “coopetition” (the collaboration between competitors) is common practice.
- Start small and with a hypothesis
- Don’t be afraid
Unquestionably, this list is not the be-all and end-all. Nevertheless, it hopefully provides a useful starting point for smaller newsrooms and outlets who would like to get started in data-journalism.
Of course, data-journalism isn’t and everything and in many respects, journalists have always been working with data in some way or the other. Even so, as the industry progresses data journalism will be increasingly difficult to avoid. “Not every journalist has to know how to scrape or to build something, but every newsroom needs to have an understanding of computer-based journalism. You do need to know what is possible, and you need a basic understanding of statistics and Excel”, says Megan Lucero.
Julius Tröger of the Berliner Morgenpost agrees. “Data journalism will become bigger. Today, even the smallest newsrooms have somebody who works with data, and there is more to come”, he says. “What we discuss internally is whether we need opulent visualizations or not. The Washington Post has 24 people working on interactive, data-driven projects, and they do great things, but maybe this is too much.” It seems that, as with many things, the right balance is key.
 The outlets interviewed for this study were Berliner Morgenpost, SZ.de, ZEIT ONLINE, Spiegel Online, Dossier, CORRECT!V, The Bureau of Investigative Journalism’s Bureau Local.
The full report “Bigger is not always better: What we can learn about data journalism from small newsrooms” is published by the Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism and can be found here.
Tags: Berliner Morgenpost, Bureau of Investigative Journalism, Correctiv, crowdsourcing, data, Data analysis, Data Journalism, Der Spiegel, Die Zeit, Dossier, gamification, innovation, Investigative Journalism, local journalism, Local News, local outlets, Local Papers, Local Reporting, Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism, Süddeutsche Zeitung